By Shamsul Islam* According to the ideological worldview of the current RSS-BJP establishment , Indian Muslims are treated as the villains of Indian history. Labelled as Babar zade —children of the first Mughal ruler—they are held responsible for every crime attributed to rulers with Muslim names, beginning with the Arab general Muhammad bin Qasim ’s conquest of Sindh in 711 CE .
By Valjibhai Patel* Rajiv Shah, who is among those esteemed journalist friends who have stood by the issues of the Dalit and oppressed communities, has raised a question regarding our 1972 protest in a recent blog, “Would breaking idols, burning books annihilate caste? Recalling a 1972 Dalit protest” ( Counterview , January 9, 2026): Why did Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar feel the need to burn the Manusmriti? Why did Periyar lead a procession crowning the idol of Rama with a garland of footwear? Why did Jyotiba Phule write so harshly against Rama, Krishna, the Gita, and Varnashrama in his book Gulamgiri? And why did we feel the need to break the idol of Krishna?